Skip to main content

← All posts

November 18, 2026

A Melbourne Cup Horse Was Found in a Skip Bin

A construction worker in Sydney opened a skip bin on Monday and found a dead racehorse inside. He filmed it and put the video on Facebook. By Tuesday, the Sydney Morning Herald had named the horse: So You Are, a five-year-old gelding who finished eighth in the Melbourne Cup two weeks earlier.

A racehorse in blue and white silks being led past a packed grandstand at Flemington before the Melbourne Cup
Protectionist before the 2014 Melbourne Cup at Flemington. Photo: Chris Phutully, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0).

He ran the Cup on November 3

So You Are lined up for the 166th Melbourne Cup at Flemington on November 3 and finished eighth, just over six lengths behind Point of Law. He had won eight races for trainer Bjorn Baker. Thirteen days later he was dead: a severe bout of colic sent him to REC Equine Specialists, where emergency surgery could not save him. The clinic euthanized him under anesthesia on Monday, November 16.

The body took a wrong turn after the clinic

After his death, the clinic's contracted service provider took So You Are to a licensed landfill, the Cleanaway Lucas Heights facility in southern Sydney. That part followed the rules: under New South Wales guidelines, a licensed landfill is the preferred destination for a horse euthanized with drugs.

The breakdown came in the handling. The body arrived in a small tipper truck barred from the tipping face, so workers moved it into a skip bin to reach the burial site. That was the bin the worker opened. Racing NSW said the horse was later properly buried and had been awaiting burial when the video was recorded.

Three apologies, one investigation

Dr. Jonathan Lumsden, managing partner of REC Equine Specialists, said the horse should have been promptly and respectfully buried, called what happened unacceptable and disrespectful, and apologized to the horse's connections. Baker said he was deeply distressed by the footage and that the horse deserved dignity and respect after his death. Racing NSW called the handling distressing and completely unacceptable and opened a formal investigation.

Cleanaway, which runs the landfill, said the transfer followed established procedures for a truck that could not reach the tipping face. Nobody has said the burial was illegal. The argument is about the gap between legal and decent, and who watches the handover once a horse leaves the clinic.

Every owner faces the same question

So You Are's story is extreme, but the question behind it is ordinary: what happens to a horse's body after it dies? In the United States the options are burial, cremation, rendering, landfill, and composting, and the rules are set state by state. Minnesota requires the body to be dealt with within 72 hours. Private cremation runs $600 to $2,000 for a 1,000-pound horse, and returns the ashes. A horse euthanized with barbiturates carries drugs that poison scavengers, so some states bar burial of a chemically euthanized horse outright. New South Wales has no crematorium for racehorses, which is why landfill is the default there.

Most owners never choose in advance. The horse dies, the vet asks what to do with the body, and the owner decides while grieving. That is when a body ends up in the hands of a contractor the owner never met, on a truck the owner never saw.

Ask your vet this week, while the horse is alive, who collects the body and where it goes. Write the answer on the stall door next to the vet's number. A plan made on a calm day is the only part of this story an owner controls.

Parts of this blog were written with AI assistance and reviewed by the Paddock team.

Less time chasing money. More time with horses.

Paddock runs the day for farriers, equine therapists, boarding barns, riding instructors and trainers: the schedule, reminders so clients show up, bills they can pay by card, and stalls and chores. Anyone can list a horse for sale, free.

Sign up