The hammer fell at $460,000 on Thursday at Keeneland, and Tip Top Thomas walked out of the ring bound for Dubai. The four-year-old colt by Volatile, winner of last year's Indiana Derby and runner-up in the Champagne at two, topped the November Horses of Racing Age Sale. Blandford Bloodstock signed the ticket. The price was the story and the footnote at once: the top of this sale was thinner than last year, and nearly everything else sold.
The top price fell by nearly two-thirds
Last year this same sale was topped by Bishops Bay at $1.3 million. This year the top lot brought $460,000, and gross fell 25 percent to $7,798,000 for 84 horses. The average slipped 4 percent to $92,834. The catalogue was smaller too: 136 horses listed against 216 a year ago, and only 87 went through the ring.
The middle of the market was stronger
The median tells the other half. It jumped 31 percent, from $40,000 to $52,500. All but one horse found a buyer, a clearance rate of 99 percent, with two more placed after the ring. The money spread wide instead of piling on one lot.
The lots under the top one back that up. Tiztastic, the Louisiana Derby winner and a $1.8 million earner, sold to Winchell Thoroughbreds for $400,000. Salamis, last year's Hollywood Derby winner, went to Fergus Galvin for $350,000. ELiTE consigned the top lot and led all consignors with $3.2 million for 32 horses.
The breeding stock sale set the tone
The racing age sale closed a week that was strong at the top end. Keeneland's November Breeding Stock Sale, which ended Wednesday, drew $240.9 million through the ring, the second-highest gross since 2007, and $253.1 million counting post sales. The average set a record at $127,324, and 25 horses brought $1 million or more, the most since 2007. Quietside, in foal to Nyquist, topped the whole sale at $5.2 million, and weanlings that had never run were bringing seven figures in the same week.
Put the two sales together and the picture is consistent: the very top of the breeding market is booming, while the racing age market is thinner at the top and deeper in the middle. That split matters for sellers. A racehorse with form still finds a buyer at Keeneland, and the median says the buyer will pay more than last year. The horses that struggle are the ones priced for a top lot that is not there. It is the same lesson MyRacehorse's Keeneland wind-up showed from the fractional side: the horses moved, but the returns came back smaller than the headlines.
For anyone holding a racehorse to sell, the lesson from Lexington is plain: price for the middle of the room, not the record at the top of it. The room paid $52,500 in the middle and bought nearly everything offered.