Thursday morning, Magnitude was the 6-1 fifth choice in the $7 million Breeders' Cup Classic. By Thursday afternoon, he was retired. A positron emission tomography scan "revealed some disruption in the suspensory fibers of his left fore," trainer Steve Asmussen told the Daily Racing Form. After talking with owners Ron Winchell and David Fiske, the decision was to "err on the side of caution and not take any risk with a tremendous horse."
Magnitude had been training at Keeneland since September. The 4-year-old son of Not This Time retires with eight wins from 15 starts, two Grade 1 victories including the Dubai World Cup, and $9,626,365 in earnings. Coolmore's Ashford Stud will stand him for the 2027 season.
The scan sees what X-rays miss
Positron emission tomography is the most sensitive imaging available for the equine limb. The horse is injected with a radiotracer that concentrates in areas of abnormal bone or soft tissue, and the scanner builds a cross-sectional picture. In the early UC Davis work, PET found lesions in fetlocks and carpi that did not appear on X-ray, CT, MRI, or scintigraphy. The modern MILE-PET unit scans a standing, lightly sedated horse, which removed the anesthesia barrier that kept earlier scanners out of training barns.
One of the things PET picks up is damage at the suspensory ligament's attachments. That is what ended Magnitude's career.
The suspensory fails the way bridges fail
The suspensory ligament runs down the back of the cannon bone and props up the fetlock. Every stride at racing speed loads it with several times the horse's body weight. Damage accumulates in the fibers long before the horse shows a limp, and a partial disruption can become a complete rupture in one bad step. A ruptured suspensory in a racehorse is often career-ending.
That is why "some disruption" was enough. The scan did not find a limp. It found the limp before it happened.
Seven horses for $7 million
The scratch leaves seven in the Classic, the smallest field in the race's history, according to US Racing and Horse Racing Nation. It also removes the one horse that had already beaten the two favorites: Magnitude defeated both Forever Young and Sovereignty earlier this year. The Classic runs this afternoon at Keeneland, and the horse that knew how to beat them both will be heading to Versailles instead.
Also at Keeneland today: Miss Yechance runs in the Turf Sprint after going through the Championship Sale.
Caution is the story, not the scratch
The interesting line in this whole episode is not the scratch. It is Asmussen's sentence: err on the side of caution and take no risk with a tremendous horse. A generation ago, a horse with a suspensory finding this subtle might well have started. The imaging got better, and the standard of care moved with it.
Clinical lasers have shrunk suspensory branch lesions on ultrasound in controlled trials (red light therapy), but detection is the tool that saved Magnitude.
Scan the legs before the entry box, not after the breakdown. A Thursday PET scan cost Magnitude a start. It may have saved his life, and it preserved a stallion career.