On December 5, in Jiangyin, China, the FEI General Assembly votes on whether international dressage keeps its final score. The FEI Dressage Technical Committee wants collective marks gone from the score sheet entirely. Of the federations that answered the consultation, only British Equestrian backs the removal. Germany, the European Equestrian Federation, and the Swiss federation want two collective marks instead of none.
The collective mark is the judge's overall verdict
A dressage test is scored movement by movement, each one marked from zero to ten. Then the judge gives one more mark, the collective, for the performance as a whole. That single number captures what the movement scores cannot: the harmony between horse and rider and how well the work follows the training scale.
The overall mark has already been cut back once. In 2018 the FEI abolished the old final scores for rider position and seat. General Impression replaced them, and on January 1, 2026 it became a single mark for Harmony, judging cooperation, lightness, the aids, and the training scale. Coefficients weight it inside the final percentage.
The FEI says harmony belongs in every movement
The technical committee's case is that a separate overall mark adds subjectivity. A judge who has just watched a test forms a broad impression, and that impression can drift away from what the movement scores said. The committee argues that harmony and the training scale should be judged inside each movement score instead, where the evidence for them is visible.
The committee points to Nottingham Trent University research in support. British Equestrian argues that dropping the collective mark makes scoring simpler to explain and leaves less room for unconscious bias.
Europe's federations want the opposite
Germany's federation and the International Dressage Riders Club asked for two collective marks: one for the rider, one for the horse. The European Equestrian Federation and the Swiss federation proposed the same split in different words, one mark for the training scale and one for harmony. Their position is that a test needs a place to reward the whole partnership, and folding everything into movement scores buries the judgment that matters most.
Nobody disputes that harmony matters. The fight is over where it gets measured: in a separate box after the final halt, or inside the scores given all the way through.
What trainers should watch
If the vote passes, international score sheets from 2027 show movement marks only, with no overall number. Training priorities shift with the sheet. A rider can no longer count on a strong final impression to lift a test with weak moments; the judge has to find the harmony inside each movement.
Spectators lose the single number that summed up a test, which British Equestrian calls simpler and its opponents call a loss of information. The change would not reach national competition in Britain, where collective marks stay at lower levels to teach riders.
The test revisions for 2027 are a separate piece of work, not proof the collective mark is already gone. It is the second major rule fight this month: USDA also reopened its soring rule for comment on November 13, and USEF's November welfare town hall covered hair testing and a proposed 60-day suspension. The vote on December 5 decides the dressage question. Trainers planning their 2027 season should read the final approved rules before the first entry, not the draft.