Steel costs more than it did three years ago. Gas costs more. Insurance costs more. Your truck needs tires. If your prices have not moved in that time, you are not being loyal to your clients. You are subsidizing them.
Raising prices feels terrible. Almost every farrier dreads the conversation. But the farriers who never raise their rates do not stay in business out of generosity. They stay in business by working harder for less, until they burn out or get hurt and realize the math never worked.
Here is how to know it is time, and how to do it without losing the clients worth keeping.
The signs you are undercharging
You are booked out for weeks and still barely covering costs. That is the clearest signal. If demand is high and income is flat, the price is wrong.
Another sign: you flinch when a client asks what you charge for something new, because you know the number is too low but you said it out loud already. Or you compare notes with another farrier in the area and realize you are twenty dollars behind for the same work.
The quietest sign is resentment. If you catch yourself dreading certain stops, not because the horses are bad but because the money is not worth the drive, that is your business telling you something. Listen to it.
Figure out your real number
Sit down with actual numbers. Fuel per week. Steel and supplies per month. Insurance, truck payment, phone, the farrier-specific stuff like forge fuel and grinder wheels. Divide by the number of horses you can reasonably do in a month without destroying your body.
That number is your floor. Your price needs to be above it with room to spare, because horses get sick, trucks break down, and you need slow weeks to exist without panic.
Most farriers who do this exercise find they should have raised prices a year ago. That is normal. It does not mean you did anything wrong. It means costs are quiet and steady, and nobody sends you a notice when they pass your rates.
How much to raise
Five to ten percent is the standard move. On a $150 shoeing, that is $8 to $15. Enough to matter across a full book, small enough that no reasonable client blinks.
If you are badly behind, you may need more. Do it in steps if you have to, but do not stretch it over years. One clear increase beats three awkward ones.
Round numbers. $160 is easier to say and easier to pay than $157. Your price list should be numbers you can state without hesitating.
How to tell clients
Tell them before the appointment, not during it. A short text or a note on the invoice a cycle ahead: "Starting January 1, trims go to $65 and shoeing starts at $175. Thanks for understanding."
January is the natural time. Everyone expects prices to move at the start of the year. But do not wait for January if you are bleeding now. The best time to raise prices was a year ago. The second best time is the next invoice.
Keep the explanation short. You do not owe anyone an itemized breakdown of your costs. "Costs have gone up across the board" is true and sufficient. The clients who need a longer explanation are usually the ones looking for a reason to argue.
Expect to lose one or two
This is the part everyone fears, and it is worth being honest about. You will probably lose a client or two. They will go find someone cheaper.
Let them. The clients who leave over a fair increase were the ones most likely to haggle, pay late, or no-show. The clients who stay are the ones who value the work. Your book gets smaller and better at the same time, and the math improves on both ends.
If you lose more than a couple, the increase may have been too steep or the communication too abrupt. That is useful information. Adjust and move on.
Do it on a schedule
The real fix is to stop treating price increases as emergencies. Pick a rhythm, once a year, every January, and make it routine. Small annual increases are invisible. Big catch-up increases every four years are painful.
Put a reminder on your calendar for November: review costs, set January prices. It takes an afternoon. It is the highest-paid afternoon of your year.